Showing posts with label fractals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fractals. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Yesterday I went with Melinda to watch swifts.

wednesday

Per the website's cheerful insistence, we parked at Montgomery Park and walked three blocks along 27th to get to a lovely view of the school from the curb. But even before we could see the chimney we could hear the swifts, twittering away. When we looked up we were absolutely spellbound.

wednesday3

The sky was teeming with birds. It was memorizing. Swifts and swallows are the otters of the sky -- there is an frenetic exuberance to their path that comes from the diet of elusive bugs, but turns out looking like great fun. It lifts the spirits. The nearby hill featured about 50 or so people camped out with jackets and blankets applauding when the birds formed accidental formations. Children in the field turned into birds.

wednesday2

We gasped when a dangerous looking larger bird came darting in to sit protectively on the chimney and cheered when the mass of tiny birds chased him off. And all at once, the birds formed a spiral column and flew into the chimney.

wednesday4

I have never seen anything like it in my life. It looked like tiny pieces of black paper were being sucked in by a giant vacuum. Thousands of birds vying for space inside the chimney. After about a hundred made it inside the mass would regroup, circle around, form the column again, and it began again. To be sucked inside by fatigue and rapid blindness from the night. How do they do it? How do they keep from bumping into one another? How do they make it into the chimney so effortlessly?

I understand the chimney is kept on the school grounds exclusively for the purpose of this remarkable event. If I had money I would donate to help keep it there. Instead I suppose next year I could volunteer to man the Audubon Society table or mind the sandwich board at Montgomery Park. I could sweep bird droppings from the bottom of the flue. Something. I'll think of something.

Thursday, April 9, 2009

A Space for Time (I & II & III)

Einstein's General Theory of Relativity introduced the world at large to a concept we lovingly (or sometimes terrifyingly) know as Space-Time. This was a fundamental change in our understanding of time, which up until then had largely been thought of in a way that was radically separate from our concept of space. For Kant, for example, Time was the pure form of inner sense, and Space was the pure form of outer sense: the two were entirely separate, divided by a boundary harder than diamond. In our everyday life, space and time seem different enough to warrant such a hard division, though we are all comfortable with metaphors that cross over the line. We think of a long stretch of time for example. Einstein's insight into time as another dimension of space, the fourth dimension in particular, can be thought of as simply taking spacial metaphors for time seriously: no longer is it metaphoric to think of time as a dimension of space, that is the way things really are. The time-line is the most common way of thinking of time as a dimension, and if we have done much graphing in the Cartesian coordinate system, we are used to thinking of the x-coordinate as the dimension of time, and the y-coordinate as a single dimension of space. Most of us have at least dealt with that kind of graphing a little, and so thinking of time as a dimension, thinking of time-lines as a real sort of space, doesn't tend to strike people as quite the crazy idea that Space-Time might have once seemed to be. (Of course, relativity itself is still pretty crazy, but we're not going to worry about any of that right now: We're only concerned with Space-Time here.) The time-line, as a picture of time as a dimension of space, is in particular a picture of Diachronic Time. Paul Ricœur, in his Time and Narrative, makes a distinction between this diachronic time and Synchronic Time, which is what Heidegger called Authentic Time . The distinction between diachronic (or inauthentic) and synchronic (or authentic) time goes something like this: diachronic time fits perfectly well on a time-line, with the present moment as a single point, an instant, somewhere along the smooth and continuous line, with the past stretching out behind and the future stretching out ahead. But synchronic time, which is the lived present, does not fit this picture so well: authentic time has a special privilege of the Now, as a tripartite moment. The Now retains the past within itself, and projects itself into an open future. For synchronic time, the present moment contains the past within itself, and that past moment (as it is present in the current Now) contains the present moment as an empty possibility of the future. There is a similar structure for the future as it presents itself in the present Now, and it lends the present now a character of "being already past" just as it has a character of "having been future". Synchronic time then has a sort of fractal structure to it: The present moment contains within it the full past as a sort of crystalline structure of previous moments, (each of which has a similar structure to the present Now), as well as an opening up to an empty future that is anticipated as having the same temporal structure as the present Now, but not yet being filled. This synchronic, authentic time then is poorly represented by the time-line. The time-line lacks any kind of fractal structure, and points along it are seen as being simply divisible. Spans of time are seen as just collections of instants, and instants are completely unique, separate grains of time.

What I intend to do, in the following little labyrinth of proofs and arguments, is to describe a space that would fit the structure of synchronic time. There are a number of concepts we need to understand in order for the space to make sense, so I will go through those first, and then combine them in such a way as to have a space in which we could imagine synchronic time as spacial, as an authentic space-time.

Part I: Cantor and Infinities Bigger than Infinity

To start with, we're going to go all the way back to Georg Cantor's proof that there are different levels of infinity, or as he called them, different cardinalities. (As it turns out, Cantor is pretty much essential to this whole argument, as he came up with one-to-one correspondence as well as cardinality, and I make some pretty heavy use of both of those concepts here.) First it is clear from the start that there are an infinite number of counting numbers: it is impossible to imagine a number that one counted to that one could not continue counting from. This is a round about way of saying that starting from 1, if you count up by whole numbers, 2, 3, 4, 5 and so on, you'll never reach a stopping point. [The round about phrasing is to avoid the phrasing "it is impossible to imagine a number which could not be counted beyond" as there are in fact infinite numbers, and counting from or to them is impossible, but then we're getting off track.] So we have our first sort of infinity, the infinity of the natural numbers. We can then call this natural or countable infinity, and any infinite set that can be systematically numbered with the counting numbers will be said to be countably infinite.
There are a lot of countably infinite sets of numbers. For example, the even numbers are countably infinite, 2, 4, 6, 8..., as are multiples of three and any other set of multiples. While it might seem at first that there would be fewer multiples of two or three than there are counting numbers in general, it is not terribly hard to see that one can set up a one-to-one correspondence between the counting numbers and any set of multiples of some given counting number, and that given any counting number, one would be able to decide where in a list of all of the numbers you could find its counterpart among the multiples by multiplying by the number in question. For example, if I wanted to know what the 56th even number is, I just multiply 56 by 2, to get 112. So 112 is the 56th even number. This process can also be reversed, and so one can find out which place in line any given even number is in. The same holds for multiples of three or any other countably infinite set.
Now, looking for a set of numbers that is not countably infinite is tricky. We might start by thinking of the integers, because we would be doubling the number of numbers we have. But then just like the even numbers and the counting numbers, it is not hard to line up all of the integers in a row if we only alternate back and forth between positive and negative numbers: 0,1, -1. 2, -2, 3, -3, and so on.
Rational numbers, also might seem to be a set that is bigger than the counting numbers, and it is hard to see how one might go about numbering them all for there are an infinite number of rational numbers between any two counting numbers. So between 1 and 2 there is 1 1/2, 1 1/3, 1 1/4 and so on, and that's just the numbers with a 1 in the numerator. But we can get kind of tricky with how we organize the rational numbers and then we can line them up one-to-one with a list of counting numbers no problem. The way that I have seen this done time and again goes this way:

0 1 2 3 4 5
1 1/1 2/1 3/1 4/1 5/1
2 1/2 2/2 3/2 4/2 5/2
3 1/3 2/3 3/3 4/3 5/3
4 1/4 2/4 3/4 4/4 5/4
5 1/5 2/5 3/5 4/5 5/5

We arrange the rational numbers in a chart like the one above: it shouldn't be too hard to see that this chart can be extended infinitely to include every possible positive rational number, and since we know that adding in the negatives isn't troubling, that's enough for now. Now we just need a way to work through the chart systematically to get all of those rational numbers into a line so we can count them and decide who is first and who is second and so on. We so this by going through in successive diagonals, starting from zero and working our way down. There are a few decisions to make (do we zig zag? Go just one direction over and over? Which direction?) but once we make them we get a nice list of rational numbers that will include them all in a way that lines up with the counting numbers without problem. To demonstrate, we could proceed this way: 0, 1/1, 2/1, 1/2, 3/1, 2/2, 1/3, 4/1, 3/2, 2/3, 1/4.... and so on, each time moving from the top right to bottom left, and proceeding across the top row one number at a time. So even though there are infinite rational numbers between any two counting numbers, we can in fact line up the rational numbers to be counted, so they are countably infinite, of the same cardinality as the counting numbers.

Which brings us to the Reals. Real numbers include numbers like pi, the square root of two, e, and such. They are numbers that are not necessarily representable by a given ratio, but perhaps only by an infinite sum of ratios (this is what the decimal notation of a real number really represents: pi is 3.1415.... which means pi is 3 + 1/10 + 4/100 + 1/1000 + 5/10000 + etc etc). Many many (so, so so many) real numbers then are not yet represented by either the counting numbers or the rational numbers, though those numbers can be included among the reals. It can be troubling to think about numbers that "go on forever", even if we do acknowledge or (dare I say) understand that numbers like pi or the square root of 2 are numbers that are like that, but we can just think of them as being represented by unique sequences of the digits 0-9 that have no termination. This is in fact what Cantor thought about when he did his proof, so it will work well enough for us. Just as it is easy to see that there are an infinity of counting numbers, it should be easy to see that there are an infinity of infinite ordered strings of the digits 0-9. In fact, as a string of numbers gets longer, there are more and more possible strings: for a single digit string, there are 10 possibilities, for two digits 100, for 3 digits 1000 and so on. So if we imagine the set of all possible strings of numbers, including infinite strings, then we are in the same head space as Cantor when he discovered an infinity bigger than infinity. Cantor argued like this:
Say we could make a list of all possible strings of the digits 0-9. Like our list of the rational numbers, this would mean that we would have a complete one to one correspondence with the counting numbers for the set of all strings of numbers. But if such a list existed, it might be possible to construct a string that was not on the list at all, which would mean that the list was incomplete. Cantor's method for constructing such a number works like this: since we (hypothetically) have our list of strings, we just start at the top and work our way down, constructing our string of digits one digit at a time, but making sure each digit that we add is different from at least one digit of at least one string on the list. So we start with our first digit, and we look at the first digit of the first string on the list. Whatever that first digit of that first sting is, we pick a different digit for our magic number. So now we have a one digit string that is different than the first string on the list. Then we look at the second string on the list, but we only look at its second digit, and whatever it is, we pick a different digit for our second digit. Then we have a two digit string that is different from the first and second strings on the list. We move to the third string and look only at its third digit, and so on. This is what is called the diagonalization proof, as we proceed down the list of strings diagonally, differing one digit at a time from every string on the list. We can see that no matter how the list is arranged, it cannot have our number on it, for our number differs in at least one place from every number on the list. So no matter how we arrange a list of all possible infinite strings of digits, we can never complete such a list, and it will never have a one-to-one correspondence with the counting numbers.
This is to say that there is an infinity bigger than infinity. We can see now that while both the counting numbers and the set of all strings of digits are both infinite sets, the second set is bigger than the first, and so we say with Cantor that it is of a higher cardinality.
This is a mind warping concept, and its implications are staggering. But it is also proved beyond the shadow of a doubt given the concepts of number and infinity. And again, so long as we can count, we have both of those concepts. So anyone that can count already has the ingredients in their head for this infinity bigger than infinity. Which is already pretty crazy.

Briefly then before we move into bringing together space and number, we should note that there are a countably infinite number of primes. This is proved by the following: Say there were finite primes, and you knew them all. Multiply them all together, and then add one. You will now have an odd number that is not a multiple of any of the primes in your list. So if there are finite primes, there is at least one more prime. So there are infinite primes. And since the primes are a subset of the counting numbers, and every prime is finite, we know they are countably infinite.

With that, we turn to the application of number to space.

Part II: Numbered Space

A: Squeezing Space Into Space

The Cartesian Coordinate System gives us a way of pairing up numbers (whether just the counting numbers, or the rationals, or all the way up to the reals. We could get real crazy and throw the imaginary numbers and other sets in too, but none of that needs to concern us right now) with points in space so that every single point in a space corresponds to a set of numbers. The most familiar variant of this system is the one with two variables, nearly always referred to as x and y. The x-y plane gives every point of space within an infinite plane (that is oriented about a center we call the origin) a pair of numbers that identify it uniquely (e.g. (0,0) is the origin, (1,1) is a point directly northeast of the origin (at a distance equal to the square toot of 2) and so on) and, when we are working with the reals, there is no point within the plane that does not have its own unique pair of numbers to identify it. The real coordinates completely describe the plane, they match up exactly with every point in the space.

We should pause here and note that Descartes' coordinate system is a monumental achievement in the history of ideas. We have in it a link between space and number. With his system, we can easily translate numerical relationships into spacial ones, and (with somewhat greater difficulty) create numerical relationships that correspond to spacial ones. Descartes' coordinate system allows us to graph, to draw out, to make visible, relationships of number that lie hidden from obvious view in an algebraic system. And it allows us to take spacial relationships and turn them into relationships of number, algebraic equations can be derived from a particular curve, cluing us in to variables, hinges of one sort or another, points of interest or importance that would otherwise be invisible to the naked eye. With Leibniz and Newton's calculi then, we find that the smooth continuity of space can be captured in numerical in numerical relationships. They bring the infinitely divided into the realm of number, and in doing so make it clear just how tightly the realm of number and the realm of space can be. It is by thinking of time as a kind of space that this numeric-spacial system is brought to bear on the world as a whole: modern science consists in large part in fitting numerical and spacial models (which are one and the same thing after Descartes, reinforced by the Calculus) to the data of the natural world. The smooth continuity of the real numbers are brought to bear on the dynamic, temporal relations of the natural world and presented to us in terms of static spacial relations. The arc of a ball thrown into the air becomes a static parabola, its changing speed a simple angular line, and its negative acceleration becomes a constant number which represents the ever present force of gravity that determines its curve through the air.

And here's where the properties of the reals begin to get interesting. Because every point in the plane can be represented by a unique pair of numbers, it is possible to encode the entire, infinite plane within a finite line segment. This can be proved in the following way: say we want to encode an infinite plane of two dimensions within a line segment that consists only of all of the points along the x-axis between x = 0 and x = 1. To accomplish this squeezing of the entire plane into this piece of a line, we need a way to encode the coordinates of each point into a single number. That this can be accomplished is a direct consequence of Descartes' coordinate system. Since every point can be represented by a pair of numbers, we only need to construct a unique real number for each pair of coordinates, and make sure that each number is less than one but more than zero. To do this, we first convert our coordinates into binary. This is non-problematic: any given number can easily be converted from one base to another. 11 in binary is exactly the same thing as 3 in base ten, and it is also the exact some thing as 10 in base three. The base system determines the way we name a given number, but it does not change the number in any way. Decimals and real numbers can be handled just as well in binary as in base ten. So: now every point in our plane is given by a unique pair of real binary numbers.
Now what we do to get those two numbers to become one is interlace their digits. This will best be explained by an example. Say the pair of numbers we want to turn into a single number is the point (1101001.1101, 11011.1). We construct our unique new number by placing each digit of the x-coordinate in a place in our new number that is the next successive even digit, and we place each digit of our y-coordinate in the next successive odd coordinate. So our number will begin this way: 0.11110011010 and then we hit a hitch: we have a decimal in our y-coordinate that needs to be represented somehow. But since our new number does not have to be binary, we can just represent the decimal by the number 2. So then our complete new number to represent this particular point in space will look like this: 0.11110011010211201010010000000000000000.... This is a unique real number that symbolizes a single point in the x-y plane. We can decode this number by pulling out our digits one at a time and placing them in order in the x and then y coordinates, which will get us back to the point we started with. It is also true that if you put an even number of zeros in front of our new number, it will encode the same point (eg. 0.00001111001101021120101001000....), and so there are in fact an infinite number of numbers between one and zero that encode this particular point in the system we have set up. And that is true for every point within the space: any given point that is given by a pair of real numbers (which exhausts the x-y plane) can be encoded in this way to become a unique real number that only encodes a single point. And so we have fit the entire infinite x-y plane into a finite line segment.

In fact, this sort of transformation is a necessary condition for the possibility of computers. We must be able to reduce spacial relations into particular strings of numbers in order to do any sort of computation involving those relationships. The method I have described is not at all like the methods used in actual computing, but we can do a lot of things with computers that are possible only with finite strings of digits, and I am here working outside of the finite realm. I could have made an effort to match in one way or another the sorts of processes that are used in computer science, but so long as my method makes any sense at all it was not necessary that I confine myself to those patterns. There are an infinite number of ways to do the sort of encoding I am discussing here and each of them demonstrates equally well the point I am trying to make: a relation that consists of a set of pairs of numbers can be equally well represented with a set of individual numbers. This is to squeeze a plane, a two dimensional space, into a line, a one dimensional space.

But what if instead of the x-y plane we were dealing with the x-y-z space? Or even some higher space? With a slight modification of this method, we can encode a space of any number of dimensions (even an infinite number of dimensions, though only a countably infinite number). This is possible thanks to the infinity of the primes: rather than giving each digit the evens or the odds, we divide up our digits by prime powers. So for a 3 dimensional plane, we would only use the digits in the places numbered by the powers of 2 (the 2nd digit , 4th digit, 8th digit and so on), the powers of 3 ( 3rd, 9th, 27th...) and the powers of 5 (5th, 25th, 125th...). This will result in a number that consists mostly of zeros, but it will encode any number within the x-y-z space, and will have room for any number of dimensions you want to add into it. This means we can encode infinite space of infinite dimension within the real numbers between one and zero. All Possible Space, in a little line segment. And when you get right down to it, we didn't even use all that much of the space we had.

So this is fine and dandy, but it still leaves something to be desired. A line segment is still a space of its own, so it doesn't seem quite totally ludicrous that we fit all the space in it (not as ludicrous as things are about to get anyway). We can see, even, that it would be possible to fit all of this space in smaller and smaller portions of the line segment: just throw a whole bunch of zeros at the front of every one of your numbers: presto! Now you're in a much smaller space! But then any portion of the line segment, we can see, is infinitely rich. Any portion of the reals has the same sort of cardinality to it as the reals as a whole have. But what about a single point along that line. Would it be possible to encode all of the space that a line segment has within it (which is rich enough to encode all possible space) into a single, solitary point? Into just one real number?

B: Squeezing Space Into Number

Yes. Well a single point anyway. Though our number might not be a regular real one. It looks like we're going to have to take another step into the wide wide world of numbers and use a hyper-real, or an infinitesimal. A hyper-real is a number that is bigger than infinity. And infinitesimal is what you get when you divide one by a hyper real. As it turns out every infinitesimal is 'very close' to some particular real number, so in what we're about to do I like to imagine that we are working with a particular infinitesimal number, which would then be a given point along the number line. This point will be located in a one dimensional space then, but the point itself, as a particular number, will be of zero dimensionality. We are going to be thinking a lot about the numerical expansion of this particular infinitesimal, and we should not confuse the numeral with the number, but we should remember also that the numeral corresponds to a particular number. There will be some discussion of complications surrounding these issues at the end of the section.

What we are going to do here is look at a construction of an infinite series of digits, but the way that series of digits is arranged necessitates that we have an uncountably infinite number of digits. This sounds kind of crazy, but so long as we keep things well ordered then it won't be so crazy as to be meaningless as we will retain the ability to differentiate our number from another. The important thing is to get every single infinite string of digits that would serve to represent a real number between zero and one into a single well ordered string of infinite digits. If we do that then we have a single string of digits (which then has the same sort of being as a real number, even if it doesn't quite qualify as one) that includes within it a representation of every real number (we're just going to deal with reals between zero and one, but that's just as many as all of them, thanks to the craziness of infinity) and so then based on what we've said above this string of digits could encode for every possible space of countably infinite dimension. This can be done.

We can show this by the following: we are going to start, much like Cantor did with his list of all the reals, by assuming that we have a representation this number already. We (hypothetically) know that we are looking at it, and we are going to refer to this behemoth of a number by the symbol B. Now we just need to show that there is a way to find within our numerical representation of B, which is an infinite string of digits, a representation of any given real number. To do this, we need to know some properties of B:
First: the numerical representation of B that we are dealing with consists only of the digits 0,1,2, and 3.
Second: Every real has been encoded only in binary: just using the digits 0 and 1. When we look at B, any place we see 0's and 1's is a particular real being encoded.
Third: the 2's and 3's in B are called signposts and are a kind of guide. They are to be understood as a second kind of binary in which a 2 is a zero and a 3 is a one. So for example the number three (normally 11 in binary) would be represented by 33, the number eight (normally 1000 in binary) would be 3222 and the number zero would be a single solitary 2.
Fourth: Each signpost number is surrounded to the left and to the right by a unique infinite sequence of 1's and 0's
Fifth: The solitary 2 representing zero in our secondary type of binary occurs only once within B. Thus out of the possible sequences 121, 120, 021, or 020, only one of the four can be found in B, but one of the four must be found.
Sixth: to the left of the 2 that is zero there is exactly one occurrence within B of the solitary symbol 3 bordered by 1's and zeros. So either 131, 130, 031 or 030 occurs just once to the left of the 2 that is zero. The same is true to the right: the solitary 3 occurs just once to the right side of the 2 that is zero.
Seventh: Now, counting upwards in signposts, our binary made of 2's and 3's, we find to the left and to the right of each signpost an instance of the next higher number that can be found without moving past any signpost of lower significance (from the right hand 3 for instance, there are two instances of the symbol 32 to the left, but only one of those is to the right of the 2 that is zero; the other is the 32 that is to the right of the left hand 3).

We can get an idea of the organization of B by looking at this fractal:



Looking at this picture, we can think of this fractal structure governing the construction of B. If we were to draw a horizontal line across the centers of the circles and then think of that line as the numerical representation of B, each place where a circle intersected the line would be the location of a signpost number consisting of 2's and 3's, and and space between would be filled with 1's and 0's encoding our real numbers.

Now: we find any given real between 0 and 1 (encoded in the binary of 1's and 0s) in the following fashion: Let 1 signify the left, and 0 signify the right. Starting with the first digit of the real in question, we ask: is this digit a one or a zero? Now, from the 2 that is zero, we make a decision about which signpost to traverse to based on that first digit, if it is a 1, left, if it is a 0, right. At each signpost we arrive at, we check the sequence of 1's and 0's to the left and to the right of the signpost we have just arrived at. That sequence will begin (from the signpost, reading to the right as normal on the right, but reading to the left if not) with the sequence we have used to decide our course so far. If either of those sequences is the real we are looking for, then our journey is complete, otherwise, we look to the second digit to decide which direction to move in to navigate to our next signpost.

Looking at the fractal image above as a symbol of B, we can think of ourselves as a traveler in a branching tunnel. We have in our hands a particular real that we are looking for, and it serves as its own address within B. It is a map to its own house, in a way. The series of digits in the real we are looking for guides us through the tunnels until we arrive finally (perhaps after an infinite number of choices) at exactly the real we were seeking.

So then: B is a string of digits that can be found in a representation of a hyper-real number (since a given hyper-real has an infinite number of digits) and which contains all possible reals.

C: Wait, really?


This should strike us as immediately problematic, since a given real can only have a countably infinite number of digits, and it is clear that B must have an uncountable infinity of digits. But: the place within B that we find any given real will not be given by a digit that can be counted to, since there are an infinite number of digits between any two signposts within B. And so we are dealing with an uncountably infinite strings of digits. If we were to attempt this sort of trick with a normal real number, we would have to start from the beginning of its numerical representation and just count out to the right until we find the real we are looking for which would be impossible even if the reals were countable: we would never get past the first real number we got to. B then cannot be located within itself, as it cannot be given (as the reals we are used to can be given) starting with its first digit and moving one digit at a time to the right until all its digits are accounted for. B contains a real infinity (rather than a countable infinity) of digits. B should be considered to be a hyper-real, or an infinitesimal rather than a real. In either case, its numerical representation is a well-ordered infinite sequence of the digits 0, 1, 2, and 3 and so should be considered the representation of a unique, particular number without any more qualms than the numerical expression for square root of two or pi or any other real is considered to correspond to a number. That our normal system of naming reals is inadequate to name B is no surprise: there are even an infinite number of reals that can not be indicated in any finite way. Certain reals, the ones we are familiar with, like pi, e, the square roots of non-square numbers and such, are special and interesting because they are real numbers that seem to contain infinite information, but can be indicated precisely with a finite, ordered symbolic sequence. Or a picture of a particular spacial ratio, more often than not. But besides these reals that can be easily indicated in any number of ways by a finite sequence of symbols or a picture of some particular spacial ratio, there are an infinite number of reals that cannot be so indicated in their particularity, but only suggested by a sequence of digits understood to go on forever. The number 5.829864321987653287432873487653932083.... cannot be said to have been given in its entirety, and indeed, if that is to be understood as a particular real, it implicates in fact an infinite field of possible reals, even if we only mean by it a single number from within that field.

There is no systematic way to name every real. And while every real can in fact be symbolized by an infinite sequence of digits, that in no way guarantees a finite symbolic pattern that will identify any particular real: in fact if there were for every real a single finite symbol sequence that could name it in particular, we would have a situation similar to Cantor's diagonalization proof, unless by some strange magic we managed to have a symbol set that was as rich as the reals. Such a symbol set can be imagined, perhaps, but to decide from a given symbol from it into the real it corresponded to would take an infinite amount of information: such an alphabet would be entirely unreadable. And so B is just a particular number (or if we want to be quite careful, B as described could be any one of an entire class of numbers) that fits the description above. It is the case that there are a number of arbitrary choices that had to be made in our construction of B: each of these choices could be made differently, resulting in other numbers that share the wonderful property of B of encoding every real between zero and one and thus encoding in turn every point in an infinite space of countably infinite dimension. There is a real infinity of such numbers, and numbers that fit our description of B represent only the tiniest slice of them.

B can then be thought of as a single point of zero dimension (to be found in a one dimensional space), just as much as any single number is without dimension, that encodes the full richness of the reals, which then in turn encodes the full richness of infinite space of infinite dimension.

It is true that B does not encode itself, or any other hyper-real or infinitesimal. Three brief notes before we move on any further:

1) That a coordinate system with real numbers exhausts every bit of space that can be meaningful might not necessarily mean that it exhausts every bit of space. Thinking about hyper-reals and infinitesimals can sometimes appear to be the same sort of thinking involved in trying to answer the question, "How many primes are blue?" Since the real number system is already beyond sufficient for any possible science (since we can only ever deal with finite representations of numbers, the rationals will do just fine, thanks, and anyway it's looking more and more like we live in a pixelated universe, so let's just cut the worry about smoothness and continuity right?) it seems to be worthless to explore any sort of number that might still lie outside of that system, and indeed I have known a professor or two that was unwilling even to admit the reals themselves as legitimate numbers. Wittgenstein himself felt that set theory had just pretty much rotted everyone's head it wriggled into (though he never said it quite like that, his feelings on the matter were strong enough). But the fact of the matter is that these sorts of consequences are necessary conclusions of some very simple assumptions that we just don't want to abandon under any circumstances. Such as 'there is no biggest number'. And we could try to avoid any direct reference to infinity, but we would have to give up calculus or start thinking of it as just a fancy method of estimation, and you're going to have whole leagues of scientists and engineers up in arms if you try to send them back to the dark dark days before Leibniz and Newton came along and treated infinity as unproblematic.

2) Whether or not you want to run with me on this whole B is a number thing, it should at least be clear that whatever you can fit in a line, which can only be understood through a synthesis of all of the individual points in the line, can be gotten out of a single point understood in the proper way. It's not so much that it has to be a special sort of point as that we have to have a special sort of way of looking at it. The way we name it (the way its numerical expression is organized) and the relationships we look for in its name are choices we make, but the possibility of making those choices, e.g. the logical space necessary for encoding an infinite field of infinite dimension, is already given by the simplest assumptions about the relationships of space and number if we are only willing to follow out the consequences of those relationships.

3) As Godel's famous theorem also shows, things that represent systems of number will always be in some way inadequate of completely representing themselves. The field of number swallows up any unification made of its field into an even greater field not yet represented. But any field of number that cannot in fact be completely explored within a particular representation of natural numbers (say the real numbers or the hyper-reals for instance) can be indicated within that system with finite strings of natural numbers just as much as it can be represented within natural language or natural minds. What I mean is this: B cannot encode itself in the same way that it encodes the reals, but so far as everything I have typed here is captured by a string of data that consists of 1's and 0's, B will contain a representation of everything said here, and moreover, so far as a logical language can be represented by numerical relationships, and so far as numerical relationships can be represented by logical relationships, and so far as any logical argument or proof will always be given in a finite sequence of steps (even steps involving the idea of infinity), every logical relationship, every truth of mathematics can be encoded within a number like B, including a rigorous proof that B cannot contain a complete representation of itself. Laws of infinity can be given within finite symbolic strings. A proof of the infinity of the primes, for example, or the infinity of the natural numbers, does not require infinite steps. Infinity is a completely negative property, it is established by the absence of walls, rather than the positive being of anything in particular. And so while B cannot represent itself, or other numbers of its class, with the same completeness with which it represents the reals, it does capture every truth about itself that can be gotten at in a finite way, and a number of things that can only be gotten at in infinite ways.


We should also, finally, note that if we look only at finite strings of binary data (and living in the digital world we all are well aware of the enormous power of finite strings of binary data) it would be sufficient to construct a single real number to contain every possible sequence of 1's and 0's of finite length. This could be accomplished by simply counting in binary. 0.011011100101110111... A number of this type already contains within it every possible string of 1's and 0's that is not infinite, and is a definite real number located on the number line just as much as pi is. Such a number, thanks to our understanding of encoding information in binary data, contains within itself every book that could ever be written, every photograph that could ever be taken with a digital camera, every piece of music that could make its way onto a digital music player, every film that could ever be shown on a digital projector, any conceivable computer program, including incidentally a number of programs that would only function with an infinite number of lines of code, so long as those lines of code could be generated by some finite algorithm. If we were content with discreet data, and unconcerned with the smooth and continuous, such a number would do just fine for our purposes, and those of you feeling woozy about B can just imagine everything I say from here on out just deals with this one little real number rather than the whole lot of them. Many of the consequences remain the same, though we lose out on the sort of overwhelming quality of B's unfathomable infinity. The infinity of a real number, just a countable infinity mind you, is already stupendously, wonderfully, inconceivably large, but it can be almost easy to forget that sometime, having seen so many infinite sequences truncated after the 7th or 8th member. And so B both gives us the wonder of the smooth and continuous, and it also overwhelms. These two aspects I find stylistically important for what is to follow. But if you're just not going to stand for such ridiculousness, I hope you will at least grant me the real number which contains every finite binary sequence. With that we should be able to at least make due.

It is my intent now to show that synchronic time requires a space that is something more like B than like the number line.
We will examine that and some other possible weirdness indicated by the existence of B in Part III.

Part III: Moments of Time

So now that we've slogged through all that, we can come back to the question I opened all of this up with, the search for a space for synchronic time. My claim at this point is that it makes a certain sort of sense (the same sort of sense as thinking of a timeline as diachronic time) to think of B as a particular moment of synchronic time. The immediate temptation is to think of the 2 at the center of B as the present, with the past stretching out in one direction and the future stretching out in another, but then we would be left in exactly the same sort of position we are in with the timeline, albeit with the present moment having the special quality of being in the center. But that isn't really all that interesting. We could have just had a timeline with NOW at the center and that would have done just fine. No, the special thing about B is that it exists in a sort of crystalline state, without change, all of it at once, its complete ridiculous massive infinity. And that all at once contains within it the full possibility of every spacial relationship that can be captured by ordered sets of real numbers. If you arn't terribly into science that might not sound like all that much, but if you stick with me we might get somewhere. That every point within any given space of countably infinite dimension can be found within B also means that every relationship of points with such a space can be found. A sort of Kantian way of saying this would be that B contains within it all possible pure forms. Relationship of any sort is can be found with B.

To make sure we don't get too starry eyed: To get any particular relationship out of B one needs to have a way of translating B from numerals into whatever sort of matter you're interested in. Say you're wanting to look for color relationships, so you're going to be navigating the three dimensional field of color, and then maybe you will be wanting to put pixels of color in a two dimensional grid. To put pixels of color in a two dimensional plane requires 5 coordinates per pixel: one for each of three dimensions of color and one for each of two spacial dimensions. Looking at B then we could pull out particular reals and think of them as giving us ordered quintuplets in one way or another or we could pull a single real out and think of it as giving us a string of ordered quintuplets. By doing this we could create full color pictures by pulling out and translating reals that we find in B. In this way, because B contains every real between zero and one, we would be able to find every possible image that can be represented by pixels of color in a two dimensional plane. If we remember that software and data are digitally stored in binary, we could also see that every possible bit of software as well as every possible bit of data can also be found in B, we just need a Turing machine of some sort (a computer) to turn our 1's and 0's into something that means something. Once we start thinking about data and the vast capabilities of digital storage, we can start to think about how whole worlds could be found in B. And that's when we might start getting starry eyed to some degree if we forget that any way of translating the reals into this sort of data is going to produce almost exclusively nonsense. We find ourselves in a circumstance similar to Borges' Library of Babel, in which one can find every possible book that is 400 pages long and consists of the letters of the alphabet, commas and periods. In such a library there must exist a book that explains in detail the library itself and all its contents, but that book will only be one of countless volumes that claim to do so, and those volumes in turn will only make up a tiny slice of the vast library which consists almost entirely of completely nonsensical works. We should remember that for every world that might make sense that is contained in B there are an unfathomable number of worlds that are utter chaos, completely devoid of any possible meaning. Such is the full realm of form.

To think of B as the full repository of all form is not quite right: it only contains those forms that are representable within the reals, which is quite a lot, considering the smoothness and continuity they are so famous for, but B remains a particular representation of all the reals, of which there are infinitely many that cannot be represented within B. This is just to say that B does not contain itself, nor any number quite like it. So B is a particular arrangement of the field of smooth and continuous form. A static, unchanging being that represents countless types of change, so far as that change can be represented.

Alright: With the timeline, we have a particular form, the line, which we apply to time as its matter. The parts that make up the line, points, we think of as points of time. Now: B itself we are thinking of as a form made up of forms. It is a complete compendium of all spacial forms that can be represented by relationships of real numbers. It is only one particular complete representation of that field, of which there are infinitely many, none of which are entirely represented by B, but many of which (all those that can be) are indicated so far as they can be indicated within a logical system consisting of strings of symbols. So if we are going to think of B as a moment of time, that moment of time contains within it, in a complete, simultaneous way, all possible spacial forms arranged in a particular way. It does not contain every moment of time, as other moments of time would be things of the same sort. So it does not contain itself, nor any other complete moment of time. It contains representations, forms. But so far as time can be understood as a spacial dimension, and so far as qualities can be represented as spacial relations, this moment of time we are calling B contains within it representations of every possible (and impossible, and nonsensical, and contradictory, etc etc) spacial relation. So as a moment of time it would contain within it representations of moments of time as thought of diachronically, but it could only indicate moments of time thought of synchronically (similar to B itself) through symbolic manipulation: no moment of synchronic time could be represented in full as each is of the same order of complexity as B itself, but every arrangement of diachronic time (sensible or not) could be found within it.

Ok: That leaves us saying that this single point, this number that is represented by the uncountably infinite string of digits arranged in a fractal pattern such that every real gets its own place can be thought of as representing a particular arrangement of all possible forms, and that such an arrangement can be thought of as a unique moment of time, where another moment of time would be a different arrangement of all possible smooth and continuous spacial forms. If we're Kantians, we are going to want to say, ok, you've got the form maybe, if I allow all this craziness, but what about the matter?

What about the matter indeed. For a good Kantian, by the way, Form is a unity, a particular relationship, while Matter is a part considered as a part. If we stick with the Kantian division of Form and Matter (and I don't see any reason not to) every bit of matter is in turn a particular form. This is of course how we understand matter in the sciences at this stage: each bit of stuff can be thought of as a particular relationship of smaller bits of stuff, and it's turtles all the way down, or it's chaos at some point. But that chaos is just a formal relationship that is unpredictable, and therefore unresolvable into specific matters. We have maintained the Kantian division, and it seems to be working just dandy, so I don't see any reason to be afraid of it. Especially since it seems then that one of its consequences is that form is primary, matter is just an aspect of form, a placeholder that has not yet been resolved into pure relationship. And so far as the world can be resolved into formal relationships, it is comprehensible and intelligible, and so far as it can't, it is unintelligible and incomprehensible. If we accept then that matter either resolves further into form or that matter is merely a symbolic placeholder at bottom that only exists as a formal relation to other parts of some whole, then the world resolves into a super-complex form. So far as that form has a simultaneous existence, it can be thought of as a particular possible moment of time, or as a particular possible arrangement of forms, either of all possible forms or of some sub-set. And so the world a a simultaneous temporal totality has a form similar to B.

The question then becomes: in what way can a particular arrangement of all possible form, all possible relationship, be thought of as a moment of time? So glad you asked: within such a moment of time one will find the particular set of formal relationships that makes up your present condition, so far as that condition can be represented by formal relationships. Unless we've somehow exploded Kant's castle, the knowable universe at any given point of time has exactly this sort of being-for-us. A Heideggerian might want to stop the show here. 'Relations of Being cannot be reduced to purely formal relationships,' they might say. Well alright, perhaps that is the case, but if so I'm willing to take a step back and say that I'm not aiming at capturing anything about Being in particular, but only about our representations of Being. 'Now, haven't we found all kinds of problems with representations? And don't we want to move on from representational thinking?' Oh sure we have, and sure we do, but let's take things one step at a time shall we? We have to understand what representation is if we are going to avoid it, and there's no harm in fleshing out just one more big representation for us to avoid thinking about later on if that's what we're into. Leave me alone would you? 'But what about being-in-the-world? What about care? What about temporality? What does this have to do with facing up to your death? Didn't you mention Heidegger way back at the start? I thought this was supposed to have something to do with authentic temporality!' Alright, you've got me. I'm arguing here that even Heidegger's authentic temporality can be captured by a certain sort of representation. And it happens just when all of being shows up as having the possibility of being nothing at all. Of not-being-anything. Death for Heidegger is the ever present possibility of our own non-being. It looms. And so does B, in its way: B is a certain sort of nothing that the world turns out to be if you look at the world in a funny sort of way. All of a sudden you are reduced to a purely formal relation in a field of mostly meaningless purely formal relations that in the end are really nothing at all. Suddenly your normal understanding of time is just one representation among many. And here you are, hearing the call of conscience, your own being-here calling you through its peculiar silence. Which is the sort of way that infinity calls. By just not being anything at all. By not showing up. Infinity is a sort of absence that contains all presence. And a moment of time is a sort of particular relationship of infinite relationships. Its form is settled, we are thrown into something without having given it shape, but it is being revealed and there is always more out ahead that we have to project ourselves out into.

Let's take all of this from the perspective of a given individual: Being-here on this view turns out to be a particular arrangement of forms within a totality of possible forms arranged in some way. Either Being-here is made up of forms that can be represented by finite relationships (even an infinity of them) and can therefore be represented by a single real, or Being-here can only be represented by an infinity of infinite relationships, in which case a particular Being-here (so far as Being-here could be particular in this case...) will be made up of a number of reals that are in some sort of relation to one another. This moment of time will then be, for this particular Being-here we are considering, made up of forms that are revealed and forms that are concealed. The revealed forms, those that Being-here is made up of (Being-in-the-world here is being made up of forms, not so much being presented forms, which is more Heideggerian than say Kantian: we don't have an abstract subject presented with forms, but merely an arrangement of the world that happens to be such that it can be thought of as Being-here from our outside perspective) are arranged in a particular way such that they make up a particular being here: there is the situation, given as pre-existing, the throwness of Being-here; then there are the projects, those forms given as open possibilities that Being-here can participate in. These forms are,primordially and for the most part, arranged in such a way that they do not reveal themselves as being so arranged: Being-here is just casually involved in day to day goings on, living in thein-authenticity of the they-self (which isn't so much bad as it is incomplete). In this first and for the most part, Being-here takes for granted the forms it is presented as being something other than Being-here itself. In this mode, the forms that represent the timeline are taken to be the time that Being-here finds itself in. But, given a proper re-arrangement of things, in a certain sort of moment, Being-here can find itself presented with Being-here itself: we come to find ourselves as the particular situation we find ourselves is, thrown into a world we did not choose and opened up to a field of possible projects, including the ever looming possibility of our own non-being, death. This particular arrangement of forms is the call of conscience, in which Being-here is called by Being-here's own silence to simply be what it is. Suddenly the normal understanding of time as a timelineindependent of Being-here's existence is shown to be a mere shadow, a false appearance. Time shows up as a pure moment of unfolding, unconcealing existence. In this moment, we can imagine something like B being presented within B itself. Not of course the full numerical representation of B, but perhaps a sudden realisation of the in-finity of possible presentation. A revelation of the absolute relativity of all Being-here, as only a tiny slice of the unconcealed, very nearly nothing at all. This could take many many different forms, most of which would have almost no direct relation to B as I have presented it here, but all bearing on the looming possibility of being-nothing-at-all.

To see the way in which the call of conscience necessarily takes place as a particular arrangement of forms that shows the presentational nature of presentation is to see the way in which B can be thought of as a space for lived time. This is mired in my own take on Heidegger and so it may look at first like a bunch of gobbledygook. That's understandable. Being and Time often looks that way, and I am building weird on top of weird here. The key point is this though:

Being-here is always a particular arrangement of forms. Sometimes that arrangement of forms reveals itself as an arrangement of forms.

Hofstadter's 'Strange Loop', if one is familiar with it, could be worth thinking about here. We find ourselves finding ourselves: representation can never be fully represented as such (the seeing eye can never see its own seeing) but it can be symbolized in such a way as to reveal itself as representational. In the language of Sartre's Transcendence of the Ego, we can indicate consciousness, we can symbolize it, but it can never be a proper object of consciousness. Consciousness can not become a proper object of consciousness. There are many many ways of formulating this same idea, each of which coming down to the impossibility of a true self-representation, but the inevitability of at least some partial self-presentation. For Kant, it is the necessary possibility of the addition of 'I think' to any of our presentations. Consciousness is always consciousness-of something: it is intentional. Being-here is always situated in a world. But there are special moments in which consciousness reflects, turns back on itself, and in one way or another catches a glimpse of its own un-representationality. That particular moment, that particular arrangement of forms, is when the synchronic nature of time shows up as such. It is for that reason why a timeline is incomplete: it takes for granted the structure of moments of time in order to give their arrangement relative to one another. But the arrangement of a moment of time is of the utmost importance for understanding what we are, if it means anything to ask the question, 'what am I?'

I have an awful lot more explaining to do, to be sure, and to that end we're going to turn to Borges in the next couple parts, specifically to his stories "The Aleph" and "The Zahir", to show ways we can go about thinking about something like B, and ways that maybe we should be real careful to avoid. After some of that we will look at some of the really interesting consequences of smoothness and continuity and the various ways that they affect our thinking when we are careful about them.

Monday, March 2, 2009

Babel Tower

Something I've been thinking a lot about lately is the state of academia as a microcosm for the state of culture at large. A big part of whats going on is the explosion of possible material to be studied. There has been an exponential curve of works published and research done and keeping up with it has been a rise in the complexity and extension of bibliographies and works cited portions of works published.
What his means is that it becomes a bigger and bigger task to figure out just what is going on with a given work. If I were a monk in the middle ages, academia consisted of Aristotle and commentaries on Aristotle, and later, Plato and commentaries on Plato. I am over-simplifying some, but not much. The entire compendium of Greek literature prior to Plato (that survived and was available to study) as well as everything in Latin from the same period (again, that survived and was available) was possible to consume (via reading) over the course of a lifetime. It was in fact possible to read everything that there was to talk about. And if you kept up with what was being published, you could probably ready every academic work that was making the rounds. It helped that only a tiny percentage of the population was involved in the academic structure (which was pretty much just the monasteries) and a even smaller portion of those folks were actually bothering to create new works. And again, over-simplifying for sure, but you can still go about reading every Greek tragedy and comedy and if you are serious about it, it shouldn't take you more than a year to get through all of them (the list really isn't all that long).
In any case (as what I'm saying above is a sort of idealization/exaggeration) the real point is that whatever the case was then, with the Renaissance you get a much bigger community producing a lot more material in every branch of culture. Mostly just because there were more people involved. And as populations expand, so do the numbers of painters, sculptors, playwrights, musicians, poets, philosophers, mathematicians, biologists, physicists, geologists, astronomers, architects, politicians, historians, and on and on, and this in turn gives rise to The Academic, whose job it is is to make sense of all of this outpouring of culture in one field or another, to organize and arrange it so that it can be taught. Canons are developed. This critical and meta-historical process in turn gives rise to new sciences, sociology, anthropology and psychology that had no place in the old system but grow up out of the academic world, parasitic of the critical and meta-historical work being done, these new sciences are studies of the movement of symbols, abstracting completely from anything encountered directly in the world.
Many of these fields begin to turn their interest both inward, onto themselves, and laterally, onto the other fields. Of course while all of them could never have been completely disentangled, this concentrated effort to put the tools of one field to use on another makes the tangles themselves apparent.
Somewhere along the line (a while back I suppose) the printing press gets set up all over the place, and the libraries explode. The cost to produce a record of a work drops considerably, and so copies and copies and copies are made. Transfer of information is facilitated, and recursion is encouraged.
The turn inward, the use of tools on the tools themselves, the recursive mode, produces strange effects. It starts small of course. Shakespeare has plays-within-plays. There are countless portraits of portrait painters. Philosophy questions its own questioning. This reaches a sort of fevered pitch near the end of the 19th century, as the recursive understanding that each academic field has of itself begins to look like the picture of the world is complete, or at least completable.
But no system with a causal connection to a system which it models can ever fully predict the behavior of the system modeled without infinite fractal recursion, which is impossible to produce via causation (I won't preclude entirely the possibility of such recursion just happening, but even to speculate there is to take a trip to crazy town).

Translation: just when you think you've got everything figured out, it explodes.

And so it did: the 20th century opens with a bang, or two, and a great mirror is held up: humanity gazes itself in the eye, and is both horrified and amazed. Electronic communication begins. Bright minds see already the potential of electronic storage and movement of information. The potential for broadcast. The potential for automation. The potential for abuse, and the potential for use.
Just as the printing press made production of copies cheaper, typewriters and fax machines and telephones and television and photography and on and on and on; the means of production and storage of information explode right along with the atom bomb.

And so does the academic/cultural world: the explosion of media is an explosion of possibility. There are new ways to create works, and so there are new ways to analyze, synthesize, critique, lampoon, parody, reference, allude to, echo.
Where it was once the case that allusions were a witty aside, meant to be caught by nearly all of the audience due to a shared culture (everybody's read or seen the main works of Shakespeare, etc) they become a game of reference and obscurity. We enter the post-modern period with a series of works that are announced as half-finished, but never to be completed. Contemporaries critique their mentors alongside the ancients, and alongside those other contemporaries also critiquing either the mentors or the ancients. The reaction to a given work overwhelms the work itself. Duchamp places a urinal in an art show and starts a revolution. Heidegger publishes the first half of the first half of Being & Time and then promptly abandons the project to go into poetry and stand up comedy. Wittgenstein publishes a single work as his PhD thesis, then goes into hiding to teach math to elementary school students, returns to academia to mount assaults on his previous work and dies without finishing anything else. His students publish his notes and errata. Freud inspires legions of academics of one sort or another to either worship or assault, and the quasi-religious cult of psychoanalysis becomes entangled with every academic field: it proposes to explain and undermine them all. The art world becomes ever increasingly self involved, each work reacting against other works: not, perhaps, in the mind of the artists themselves who remain for the most part inscrutable, but in the eyes of the increasingly impossible to follow world of art criticism, which goes to great lengths to legitimate itself by being increasingly convoluted, technical, and obscure.
Derrida publishes Glas, a work reacting to Hegel and conceived in such a way as to avoid being an antithesis or synthesis to any Hegelian thesis. Deleuze and Guattari engage in Chaosophy and Misosphy, building off of Deleuze's career of imaginary history of philosophy and Guattari's activism, born of the rebellions of May of '68. More television programs are produced than could be watched in a lifetime. More films are produced than could be watched in a lifetime. More books are published ever year, every month, every day, than could be read in a lifetime.

The internet is born.

[If you're keeping score, I'm not keeping things in strict chronological order, the point is the state we're in much more than just how we got here.]

Globalism and global culture rise as the boundaries between physical locations melt from the heat of information flowing freely through time and space.

More information is produced and recorded at least semi-permanently every hour than could be consumed by any individual in their lifetime.

The fields of research expand at exponential rates not completely understood by anyone involved in fueling the growth.

The cost of creating new work drops close to zero.

More than half of the world's considerable population come into possession of a cell phone (4 billion of them and counting).

Following a given academic work requires not just participating in the field from which it is grown, but being a member of the generation from which it is produced, and a follower of the movement it takes part in.

McSweeney's publishes All Known Metal Bands, a 300 page list of band names, with no further information or comment. It gets rave reviews, and sells like crazy. Many bookstore employees write recommendations for it and give it prominent shelf space.

Livejournal. Myspace. Blogger. Facebook. Twitter.

The Daily show is taken more seriously than most main stream televised news, paper newspapers decline, but internet based news and NPR thrive.

This is white noise, culturally. Every frequency sounded to the limit. No chorus. Constant change. United by a single language, English, the world is divided by a lexicon that includes over 1,000,000 living words. And far more dead ones. [Most living languages have vocabularies in the 100,000 range or less, though these are statistics I've seen in places and may not be entirely accurate, but the point remains.] A greater and greater percentage of our memory is taken up by advertisements, logos, catchphrases, and jingles designed to stick to the human mind like glue. Memeology is all the rage, as we watch ideas wage war on one another for possession of the most sought after real estate in a world where every inc of solid ground is owned by someone: the inside of your skull.

This is bad. This is good.
There is more culture now than there has ever been. You could do nothing but watch opera from now until you die, and you would never have to watch the same opera twice. The fields of cultural research are vast. The amount of raw inspiration, if sunrises and sunsets and clouds and bees and dandelions and raindrops and snowflakes and beaches and the moon's phases and the stars and all the rest of the world that has always been there and just can't be forgotten about wasn't enough for you, is functionally infinite.

But then we can't go about talking about it like we used to. We can't rely on allusion and reference to get us by. A 20 page bibliography is cute, but it's a wall that won't be broken all that often.

We have to find ways of communicating simply and directly.

We must look to each other as human beings, and speak and write and create and move in ways that are not echos for the sake of showing that we are part of a clique that has consumed some common culture, but instead echos for the sake of communicating what is beautiful or haunting or joyful or terrifying or moving in whatever way of what we are echoing.

We must learn to echo what is meaningful.

For too long it has been enough to echo in such a way that it was possible to find the source of your echo. To hunt down the original (or better, to remember) to understand what was meant by the particular reference or allusion.
"To be or not to be"
"I think therefore I am"
"The Eternal Return"
"I'm MELTING"
But such echoing can no longer take the place of meaningful communication, for the rising tide of cultural creation has made it insane to think that any serious number of humans will have read all of the same books that you have.

This is a cultural Babel Tower: we have the potential to continue to create and imagine and play with more freedom and crazier toys than anyone ever before. But if we don't stop playing like we have for the last few millennia, we're not going to be able to communicate at all, and down the tower will fall.

But really: it's as easy as taking responsibility for what you do. If you're going to echo, echo in your own voice. Stop mimicking and start doing. Authenticity is the only way out. It's that or cultural solipsism from here.

I think we can do it.

I think we should try.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Nature and Sight

for a long time

For a long time on this planet, everything was dark.

The sun shone in the day, and the moon was full every 28 days or so and the stars were out when either the sun or the moon wasn't there. Lava glowed, and sometimes when a rock fell down a hill at night or when something in the water bumped something else just right, there might be a spark here or there.
But there were no eyes to see it.
There were hills and valleys, oceans and rivers and mountains and plains, mesas and fjords and deltas and islands and beaches and rainstorms and hurricanes and tornadoes and tsunamis and tides and geysers and stones and pebbles and rocks of all shapes and sizes.
But everything was invisible, because nothing was there to see.
After a while, things started to be alive. A little at first, but after not too long there were lots and lots of things that were alive. Little by little, some of these living things began to care about whether there was light or not. There was light and there was dark. And then it was whoever could tel the difference the best did the best, found the most food, or just grew in the right direction even (plants keep track of the light too, they just dont have lenses). And so it came to be that a world that was invisible became visible.
But there was still a lot that was not seen. What was doing the seeing was eyes. And eyes have gotten better and better as time goes on (though of course some eyes have gotten worse sometimes, and sometimes rather than getting better or worse they just got different. Evolution means all kinds of things happen, and not always what makes sense) but eyes can only see so much. Eyes could not see things that were very very small for instance. Or things very very far away. Eyes could not, for a long long while, see earth as a sphere gliding through space, or see the insides of things that had eyes.
More than that, eyes could not see the past, and could not see the future.
Brains though, brains could lead to some of that.
And as brains got better, more and more was seen. Slowly but surely, ore and more of the world was becoming visible.
And so here we are. Living in a world where we can see far more than has ever been seen. We see visions of the past (photographs and films and paintings and sculptures etc etc) and visions of the future. We see big things and small things and insides and outsides.
We see the way things happen.
And we see how we see.
And we make seeing better.
And slowly but surely, we can make lots of things better.
And as Nature comes to see, she uses her sight. She acts on what she sees.
She has a trillion eyes. And they are getting better every day.
No more must evolution stumble blindly in the night.
Hey that lekking seemed like a good idea at the time I'm sure, but it's just a way to inch on down the hall.
We can run now.
We can look ahead and decide what we want to be.
And we can get there if we want to.
Our wants were formed in darkness.
But what we want is light.

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

And now for something completely legitimate



I've been getting into Micheal Palin's travel documentaries lately, for one because I'm a sucker for BBC documentaries, and also because I'm a sucker for Micheal Palin, being the Python freak that I am.

As often happens these days, I was looking up the series I'm in the middle of (Pole to Pole) on wikipedia for any extra information they might have. A garden path of digression led me to other post-python stuff, one of them being the 30th anniversary special that I'd only barely heard of, featuring Eddie Izzard playing the parts Eric Idle was too indignant to come play himself. And I thought, that's weird. Because I own essentially everything they've ever done, but I've never seen that.

I did another thing that has become pretty common: I went over to youtube to see if some lonely soul had uploaded the thing, or clips.

And let me say: I know this is piracy. I know it's wrong and scary for television like napster was scary for musicians. But I also know youtube has made it possible for me to watch all of the UK version of Whose Line Is It Anyway, which to my knowledge is not available on DVD in the states, certainly not through netflix or my library.

Let me also say that were I in the position to BUY the stuff I would do it in a heartbeat, because at this point I've watched series 5-10 of WLIIA several times over. I am an Extreme Dork when it comes to stuff. I want the funny, and I want ALL of it. But I am not in such position, because I am a broke self-employed illustrator. So what to do?

The Pythons themselves decided to approach the problem in this way:



Which I think is pretty brilliant, along similar lines as the various bands putting their albums up on their own websites, avoiding the labels. I don't know that it will give them any revenue, but I know that once I've seen something enough that I want to see it at weird hours when I can't get internet at my apartment, it's nice to have a hard copy. And hopefully other people will thinks so to.

So hey. Never seen any Monty Python? Maybe you should.

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

more it plan

which would seem ungrammatical. But really.
Here's more of the planning for It (the first third)


it

What is?

Pitfalls:
**None/Some** Thing Thing Being Is fuckall.
right: lets not got too far there, differance and all that

WE"RE MODEL MAKING HERE, NO NEED TO WORRY ABOUT WHAT REALLY IS THE CASE THANKS!
Also: There is a science o the human mind specifically, and there are lots of people making models of it of various sorts. Their work is all well and good and I'm not out to say they're wrong. This is about figuring out what a mind can be. What are the elements required for a self to emerge. We must keep our eye on that

Simple/Complex
-the single simple
(parmenides)
LETS NOT THINK THESE THINGS: But: the single is really Some rather than None
And: The impossibility of simples (from the but: the simple is a complex of none and some)
LETS JUST NOTE: IT CANNOT BE A MIND
why:
Change. The end.
So we have two options:
-plural simples: complex of simples
(still one, sort of)
we have to get at least somewhat away from the simples themselves to have anything we're going to call a mind here
AND, we only technically have bottom plurality:
complexes are impossible to concretely distinguish
so they arn't really things-plural, though we can make arbitrary distinctions that work to some degree
-the single complex: complex of complex
(only sort of single, as its divisible)
And specifically a fractal one, something we can get a grip on. Normally this will imply elements, but they might never show up at any level of zoom (we can have infinite complexity down and up, just for arguments sake) Otherwise we've got mush.
every level of zoom is the same, sort of.
from any level we see simpler below (as here is composed of those) and more complex above

Only with simples do we start with many.
We don't start with simples
We don't start with many
We start with much

Much/One/Many/One
what's much? (why is that not one yet?)
So then one of much
then many one
which can be one

((We play this game here so to know what we are playing with))

{{Chaos/Order}}
[at the lowest level of zoom (at our pixels) we will have mystery as there will be no detail, hense random at that level, but order will emerge from there: random random random means pattern pattern pattern]
Unstable/Stable
this is assuming time. but we're in third person land so we get to do that.
if stable then no change
Oh! unstable then
if no stable, then just constant, ABSOLUTE (otherwise we have a gauge) change, which is ridiculous.
we need grey to make this interesting
So balance of stable from unstable
Evolution!
every system with this balance of stable and unstable (which is no archemedian point) will evolve.
simple(r) stables interact to make complexer things, etc
Village - > child
we need a lot of the same sort of simple(r)s in the same place to get complexs of them
Environment tends towards complexity
The vast proliferation of mind.
MIND: a kind of semi-stable structure (complex in nature)
that: reacts to environment
by: signals (not quite symbols, but close)
basically if-then structure of sufficient complexity to warrant treating it as such (my threshold is low, but it needent be for there to be fireworks)
any two minds that interact are a mind (by this deffinition of mind)
Symbols as complexes of signals
structure strcture makes it go
The Self-symbol is the complex of signals that react directly to the mind in which it is a symbol
so a model of the mind
so some brief implications about simplicity/complexity thereof
The rise/myth of individuals
Minds with parts that take care of themselves (and are minds too) Succeed!
individuals plural, not the topmost level, minds that deal with minds
all interactions thereof are of a bigger mind
/are signals
/are parts of symbols
yay evolve go (implications of all kinds)
As mind evolves its parts become more mindlike (towards complexity)
Culture/individual
the signal-set and hense symbol set comes from enviroment
when enviroment is a mind, the symbol set then is a gift of the enviroment and of that mind
as in, is given by it as a whole
any part of a mind is also a signal/symbol
The self symbol can be generated spontaneously, but it can be encouraged to
or prepared for
The nature/nurture debate is silly: the nurture has been determined by the nature has been determined by the
to see the way its silly is to know what I mean here
Public/Private
witt arguments about language
how deep that goes?
everything is interaction with the mind that you are made by
so. Deep.

Monday, July 21, 2008

from "Oh the Places You'll Go", by Dr. Suess





And when you're in a Slump,
you're not in for much fun.
Un-slumping yourself
is not easily done.

You can get so confused
that you'll start in to race
down long wiggled roads at a break-necking pace
and grind on for miles across weirdish wild space,
headed, I fear, toward a most useless place.
The Waiting Place...



...for people just waiting.
Waiting for a train to go
or a bus to come, or a plane to go
or the mail to come, or the rain to go
or the phone to ring, or the snow to snow
or waiting around for a Yes or a No
or waiting for their hair to grow.
Everyone is just waiting.

Waiting for the fish to bite
or waiting for wind to fly a kite
or waiting around for Friday night
or waiting, perhaps, for their Uncle Jake
or a pot to boil, or a Better Break
or a sting of pearls, or a pair of pants
or a wig with curls, or Another Chance.
Everyone is just waiting.


NO!
That's not for you!

Somehow you'll escape
all that waiting and staying.
You'll find the bright places
where Boom Bands are playing.

window

quilt

elephant

Thursday, July 10, 2008

Monkey See

Monkey Do.


[[seriously, watch as many videos from TED as possible, get a feel for what the intelligista are thinking about. then either think with them or against them, I figure it would be hard not to think at all]]

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

The Future is Everything

So here's sort of a weird little brainstorm:
We've had lot's and lots of visions of the future. Some of them seem to be coming ever closer to the truth. 1984 anyone? Brave New World? Fahrenheit 451?
But then also, The World of Tomorrow. (Check about 1:20 in to see some now from the past)

My crazy thought was this: As theres more and more of us, and things change faster and faster, more and more predictions about the future will be true, because more and more will be going on.

Eventually what you get is everytime now. Not quite everytime here and now, unless here is all of earth, but the basic idea is that everything thats been going on is still going on somewhere (travel out from urban centers and you travel back in time, back to the pre-civilized if you know the right direction to go...) and eventually, everything that we thought would be happening in the future will all being going on somewhere at the same time.

[The hyperbole is a bit much, 'everything' is aways an insane word to use. But you get my point.]

So, if globalization is about anywhere being everywhere (or is it everywhere being anywhere?), the next century might be about anytime being everytime (or the other way around if you prefer).

It's a crazy train we're riding, but it's neat!

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

We are not two we are one

I've been reading the Upanishads
at work. It's been nice. But then it was pretty crazy that you were listening to music from a movie about India, and then so was I, but by accident (it was in a car I was in).
And the song kept saying
We are not two we are one
Which is what I was writing last night.

Which is all pretty crazy.

I will probably forget about today in the long run.

I will only remember today as a border of yesterday, maybe (who knows what will happen) as a border of tomorrow. But not for itself. Today was just another day. And considering today is day TWO of the great adventure, that's pretty encouraging.

I have focused a lot of my energy into making this change into something that is more like a change in key, more like a change in rhythm than a change in band, a change in genre. The song that we sing, I want to keep singing. And I know that there needs to be a tempo change, and maybe a key change, and maybe some instruments rotated in or out. But this is all still one song for me. One song that includes cow jokes and line walking and string tears and a bucketful of magical realism.

I've been thinking a lot about HoL and how that book is a lot about the language that develops between two people that are deeply connected, how that is the only code that is unbreakable.

A pair of people can be just as solipsistic as a single person, but its way more fun with two people than it ever could be with one.

Another 10 hour day tomorrow. Goodness me.
It's kind of fun knowing that I am the equivalent of a nerve repairman. But the job is less glorious than it could be. I guess platelets don't exactly live a live of glamor. But my job, replacing broken cell phones, is more like a nerve cell cluster that controls the re-growth of nerve connections, so thats at least somewhat more complicated than just being a platelet.
Not to be down on those guys: they did their job in Windsor when the tornado hit.

Yeah. I am talking in code that only two or maybe three people understand. It is time for rest.
I think.

But.
We are not two we are one
Goodness that's important.
So Much.
So much.
We are not two we are one.




We are not two we are one

Sunday, May 4, 2008

We are a Strange Loop

So, I've been reading Doug Hofstadter's I Am a Strange Loop, and while I think Dougie (as he is sometimes called) is on to something, I'm not convinced yet that he really knows what he's on to exactly.
The book is largely (so far anyway, I'll let you know if there are any surprises) a re-telling of his earlier book, Godel, Escher, Bach, which is a detailed examination of Godel's Incompleteness Theorem, with an eye towards the magic of self-representation. Basically the idea is Ouroboros as the heart of consciousness: it is that we have the ability to model (imagine, understand, etc) ourselves that makes us conscious. That's not all that crazy of an idea; self-awareness is basically a synonym for consciousness, and it's had to imagine what consciousness without self-awareness would even mean. The exciting thing, for Mr. Hofstadter, is that this sort of self-representation is a necessary consequence of any symbol system of sufficient complexity, which, Hofstadter argues, follows from Godel's lovely theorem.
This consequence, that any (inherently meaningless*) symbol system of sufficient complexity (enough to deal with counting numbers: 1, 2, 3, 4, etc.) leads inexorably to self-representation strikes Hofstadter as the key to understanding consciousness. This I think is somewhere in the ballpark of the truth. What Hofstadter doesn't see though, are the consequences of being able to see consciousness as such a simple, universal event. He does see that this opens up the potential for A.I (he spent a great deal of GEB talking about that, but much less so in IAASL, at least so far), but he has a crucial assumption that completely covers up the most exciting thing about his way of thinking of minds: Hofstadter places individual, adult, human beings at the very top of his hierarchy of self-hood, awareness, and consciousness. This might not seem like a controversial decision to some people, but to me it seems insane; networks of human beings have a far greater potential for self awareness than any single human being ever could. The same way that an ant colony (which Hofstadter knows some stuff about) if far more self aware than any given ant (though still far less self aware than an given human being), a human colony is far more self-aware than any given human being. It's completely fascinating that Dougie has missed this (again, he may not have, and I might be speaking to soon, but this strikes me as a pervasive issue in his thought), because he does an enormous amount of thinking about networks of smaller things being outside of our perception just because of the size we are. He's ever so keen to recognize that the way we see things has everything to do with our size, but he only seems interested in seeing that there are things smaller than us, never bigger.
I suppose that part of what helps me see minds all over the place, big and small (that are really all part of the same big system, and therefore all part of the same big mind, the Homunculus is You and all that) is my thinking about the internet so much, but I think it has to do with something simpler than that too.

Just thinking about human relationships, and the fractal nature of our understanding each other.
Thinking of you
Thinking of me
Thinking of you.
We make a mind together, you and I, we we sit down and talk, or just interact in pretty much any way. We are self-aware of us together just as much as we are aware of each of us separately. Thomas Nagel, in his ever-so-famous (if not nearly enough), What it is like to be a bat, proposed that we think of conscious things as things that it would be like something to be that thing. He contrasts things like rocks and fungi, which he does not suppose it is like anything at all to be (or perhaps: it is just like being nothing), to things like bats and other people, which we often find ourselves wondering what it would be like to be. I think Thomas suffers from an impaired imagination, and I also think he does not understand the consequences of his own argument, which is mostly centered on showing that no mater how much we wonder what it is like to be a bat, we can never know at all. The thing is, it follows that we can't even know what sorts of things it is like something to be.
I propose a different solution. It is like something to be a part within a whole, and as a part in a whole, it is possible (I am tempted to say necessary) to interact with other parts within the whole. Now: it is never at all possible to draw a hard and fast distinction between some part of a whole and another part, because the interactions between them are indistinguishable from actions on the part of some bigger portion of the whole. [There may be simplest parts, each of which is a distinguishable individual, but apart from those, no composite part can be strictly delineated, because it is then composed of simple parts that must interact with BOTH composite parts of any pair of interacting composite parts. I'm only dealing with systems that do include composite parts, because systems without composite parts are boring, and I don't really think there are simplest parts of the whole we are a part of, so I am largely (except for this large parenthetical, that this parenthetical is nested in) ignoring simplest parts as well.] Then: there is always some ambiguity as to what part of the whole any given part is, and that ambiguity opens up the field of what it's like to be some other part. I can imagine what it is like to be a bat, because there is no real way to tell where the bat ends and I begin. Similarly, when you and I are together, it is impossible to draw any sharp distinction between what is you and what is me, and so it is no surprise that we start to use "we". Now: it is also always possible to make an arbitrary distinction between this thing and that thing, between you and I, but we must be careful to remember that such distinctions, while terribly useful, and while terribly difficult to avoid seeing, are no more and no less real than the distinction between a pawn and a bishop in a game of chess. We make the distinctions, and they are only as real as we make them. Once we see that, we can really wonder, and in some small way find out, what it is like to be a bat, or for that matter, a mountain, a grain of sand, an ant colony, a pair of humans, the Internet, Mother Nature, the Sun, or even The All. We are all connected, not in some mystical, wishy washy way, but just because of the nature of being a composite thing that is a small part of a great whole. Any system of sufficient complexity will inevitably include the possibility of self-awareness, and further, a system of sufficiently greater complexity will inevitably include the possibility of self-aware sub-systems.

Which reminds me of my proof that not even God can see everything. But I'll save that for next time.




*The logic that Godel worked with was definitionaly meaningless, requiring a separate interpretation schema, entirely divorced from the symbols themselves, to make any of the typographical marks anything more than pieces in a game, jumbling around according to the rules they are given (or really, composed of), churning out theorems while nobodies looking.



Edit: I may have spoke too soon, but I would hate to repeat the error, so I'm going to wait until I'm done with the book to speak on this again.